9 Best Eyeshadow Primers for Oily Lids in 2021

Those of us with oily eyelids face this problem more often than not, finally achieving the perfect eye-look only to have it crease and smudge within a few hours.

The solution? An eye shadow primer formulated for oily eyelids. It blocks the oil from reaching your eye-makeup, so there’s less creasing and smudging. And you can look glamourous all day.

To ensure that the primer does its job, you first need to determine the underlying cause of your oily eyelids. For example, certain creams and cleansers or even a hormone imbalance may make your eyelids more likely to produce excess oil. Once you figure out why your eyelids are oily you can choose the right product to fit your needs.

If you’re tired of having your eye-makeup smudged halfway across your face by the end of the day, you need to invest in the best eyeshadow primer for oily lids. Read on to discover more, so you can be sure your makeup will stay intact.

Best Eyeshadow Primers for Oily Lids Reviewed

1. Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion

Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion

Buy on Amazon

This primer by popular makeup-brand, Urban Decay is well known for a reason. Its tried-and-true formula has proven time and time again that it’s the real deal. It saves eye-makeup from creasing and smudging for up to 24 hours.

The product’s super creamy consistency allows it to glide smoothly over your eyelids, making it the perfect base for bold and natural looks. It also includes a wand applicator, so it can easily be applied where it’s needed.

To prevent creasing and smudging its formulated with polymer technology, which provides a 24-hour hold on any eye look. Urban Decay is also a vegan and cruelty-free brand, so you don’t have to feel guilty when using this product.

With this formula, a little goes a long way. Just dab a tiny amount on your eyelid with the applicator before applying your eye makeup for a look that lasts all day. It’s a staple to any makeup guru’s collection!

2. Revlon Colorstay Eyeshadow Primer

Revlon Colorstay Eyeshadow Primer

Buy on Amazon

If you’re looking for something less expensive, the Revlon Colorstay Eyeshadow Primer is a great option. Its formulated with Revlon’s color stay technology, designed to maintain the vibrancy of pigmented eyeshadow and prevent creasing.

When creating this product, Revlon had those with oily eyelids in-mind, boasting a non-greasy formula. It’s dermatologist-tested and contains a light-weight shea butter complex that will leave eyelids soft and smooth, guaranteeing the easy application of makeup.

Its universal pigment will work on all skin tones while providing a smooth and even canvas when applied before eye makeup. Patchy eye shadow will become a thing of the past.

If you’re searching for a product that provides long-lasting wear and doesn’t break the bank, this is the one for you.

3. Too Faced Shadow Insurance Anti-Crease Eye Shadow

Too Faced Eyeshadow for oily lids

Buy on Amazon

Too Faced’s formula is made specifically to stop makeup from creasing throughout the day. The product also protects from fading, melting, and blurring that is commonly caused by excess oil.

This silicone-based product makes any eyeshadow instantly easier to blend, more vibrant, and longer-lasting. Your makeup will stay flawless until you’re ready to wash it off.

Plus, it’s formulated with skin-soothing ingredients such as Vitamin E enabling it to even skin tone and smooth wrinkles and fine lines, guaranteeing a smooth makeup application every time.

The brand also guarantees that this product will lock-down your eye shadow for up to 24 hours, even if it’s exposed to water. Only a small amount of this product is needed as well, meaning that one tube will last you a long time.

Also: The Best Eyebrow Concealers for Eyes That Are Always On-Fleek 

4. Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eye Shadow Base

Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eye Shadow Base

Buy on Amazon

Obsessed with the Korean beauty trend? This product may be for you. It’s guaranteed to leave you amazed with its all-day staying power.

This formula will dry in seconds so you can start your makeup application almost immediately. The brand assures that your eyelids will remain free of oil all day long, allowing makeup to stay put.

What’s more, the product contains pearl powder that evens and brightens the tone of your eyelid for a smoother finish. It’s also weightless and non-greasy, making it perfect for oily eyelids.

The brand is so confident in their product that they will even give you a full refund if you are not satisfied, so there is no risk in trying it out!

5. Monica Ann Beauty Eyeshadow Base

Monica Ann Beauty Eyeshadow Base

Buy on Amazon

For those of you looking for a little extra nourishment, this product may be right up your alley. Its formula contains Vitamin C and Hyaluronic acid that will leave your lids feeling smooth and soft. It combats oil while moisturizing, giving you the best of both worlds.

This product is made without oil and is very lightweight, meaning that it absorbs fully into the skin; leaving you with a natural look that stays in place all day.

Love going to the gym? No worries, because this product is sweat and waterproof. So, you can get your cardio in and look great while doing it.

This product is super easy to wash off, despite its staying power! Simply wipe away with your favorite make-up remover or face wash and you’re good to go.

6. NYX Professional Makeup Glitter Primer

NYX Professional Makeup Glitter Primer

Buy on Amazon

If you love glitter as much as we do, this product might be your new best friend. It’s designed specifically to enhance and lock down the glittery shades because we all know how annoying glitter fall out can be.

The product is formulated to be smooth and lightweight, so your eyes won’t feel sticky and tacky after application. It’s also guaranteed to hold on to any eye makeup that comes its way, even if you don’t wear glitter shades this product still has your back.

At such a low price point, you can’t go wrong with this amazing primer. And it makes a perfect choice for oily lids as it has advanced adhering power.

7. ILIA – Natural Brightening Eye Primer

ILIA – Natural Brightening Eye PrimerBuy on Amazon

Staying power doesn’t have to involve artificial ingredients that may cause eye irritation. This product is 100% natural and will give your eyes that extra ‘pop’ of illumination that you’ve been wanting.

With a quick-drying formula, this product won’t let you down. And the doe-foot wand makes it so easy to apply.

It’s formulated using a blend of minerals rather than artificial colors and dyes meaning it’s safe for those with sensitive skin. The minerals absorb excess oil on the eyelid, so you won’t have to worry about creasing and melting at all.

The formula also includes a dash of shimmer and pigment. Not only does it make your eyes look brighter and more awake but it also evens out the tone for a smooth, even application every time.

This product is made with 52% organic ingredients and is vegan, cruelty-free, as well as gluten-free. It will become any natural-product lover’s favorite primer in no time.

8. Physicians Formula Instaready Eye Primer Duo

Physicians Formula Instaready Eye Primer Duo


Buy on Amazon

Are you indecisive and can’t choose between matte and shimmer eye shadows? Well lucky for you this product comes with a primer for each so you can easily switch up your look as desired.

Both of the included products are oil-free and smudge-resistant to keep you looking fresh throughout the day. Plus, they are dermatologist-tested, fragrance-free, and hypoallergenic so you can breathe easy after applying this formula.

The matte primer leaves matte shades shine-free all day long, even those with the oiliest eyelids can rock a matte look with this formula. Plus, for days when you’re feeling a little sparkly, the shimmer primer enhances the appearance of glitter and shimmer shades.

The formula will also lock glitter down in place, so you won’t end up with glitter all over your cheeks by the end of the day.

You can’t beat getting two different primers for the price of one, especially if you love to change your eyeshadow look often. This product has all of the bases covered with its versatility and gentle formula.

9. BareMinerals Gen Nude Eyeshadow + Primer (Exposed)

BareMinerals Gen Nude Eyeshadow + Primer

Buy on Amazon

If you want something with extra coverage and pigment, you’ll love this formula. It’s a primer and eyeshadow combined into one product that will easily erase any discoloration that you may have!

This product can be used by itself for a natural look or applied under eyeshadow for even application of shades. Its cream-to-powder formula dries down matte with a hint of shimmer that gives a ‘make-up free’ look when worn alone. If used with shadow, it will intensify any shade, leaving your eyes vibrant and beautiful.

This product also boasts some amazing ingredients. It has mango seed butter that softens and smooths the eyelid, green tea extract protects against free-radicals, and camellia leaf extract calms and soothes the skin.

Final Verdict

Oily eyelids are a pain for any makeup wearer, no one wants their eye-makeup smudged under their eyes and creased! To combat the effects of oil, you’re going to want a primer with great staying power so you can look your best all day long!

We curated this list to make it easier for you to find the primer of your dreams. Whether you are looking for a product that is; cruelty-free, waterproof, lasts 24 hours, or has an all-natural formula, we have you covered.

Don’t let your makeup be ruined by a little oil. Try one of our favorite primers for oily eyelids, and say good-bye to creases and smudging and hello to a long-lasting flawless look!

Have you tried and loved any of these products? Or did we miss any of the ones that you love? Let us know in the comments!


Leave a Comment